patching...
Breaking: I'll Have Another Wins Another—at Preakness »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

School Officials: iPads Won't Replace Textbooks Soon

The high price of iPads is just one of the hurdles to integrating the devices into public schools.

 

Replacing textbooks with tablets is still an impractical dream, according to some of the top school officials in the county. But the potential is growing each day.

Last week, Apple made an announcement about partnering with top school textbook publishers in the country to offer textbook apps for iPad owners. Tablets like the iPad can hold thousands of books, and stand poised to overtake bulky, paper books—so long as school systems can afford them.

But that dream hasn’t arrived yet.

Some schools have invited iPads into classrooms on a smaller scale. Prince George County Public Schools used a $1.3 million stimulus grant from the federal government to provide iPads to 3,000 students at four of its Title I middle schools, The Baltimore Sun reported.

Anne Arundel County Public Schools (AACPS) officials say they have been investigating the possibility of integrating the devices in the classroom for almost a decade, but they’ve still not found the right fit.

“The end goal is that every student would have such a device,” said Greg Barlow, chief information officer for AACPS. “But how we get there is going to be challenging, especially in this fiscal climate.”

Barlow said the announcement from Apple was exciting news to people in his field. Publishers becoming more receptive to electronic publishing would create a new landscape for textbooks, he said.

But the price point is still not right, Barlow said.

Current model iPads start at $499. The average PC costs the school system around the same price but lasts longer than a tablet, and are more functional in a school setting, Barlow said.

“At this point it doesn’t seem to be a replacement of our desktops and laptops, but an additional item, and there’s certainly no budget for that right now," Barlow said.

Once the price of these devices hits the sub-$200 range, Barlow said they could then take a serious look at the potential of integrating them in the classroom.

Moving to some kind of tablet or e-reader format would make certain parts of the education process easier, said Val Emrich, the instructional technology manager for AACPS.

“We know that students don’t want to carry around these big tomes all day. But there’s more to it than that,” Emrich said.

Testing for students has progressively moved away from papers and pencils and into the digital age. Scheduling students to access computers for tests has become a headache for some schools, Emrich said.

If each student had access to a personal device, the problem suddenly goes away.

The long-term goal, Barlow said, is that each student has a device he or she can take home. That could extend what educators call the learning day, the amount of time each student spends in school.

“They could start doing work on the bus, finish it at home. They could even start taking two languages, one at school, and one at home,” Barlow said. “We’re absolutely getting closer to that dream."

Broadneck High School junior Pablo Escobosa said the books he uses in classes often have no covers. They're also subject to the graffiti and markings of the hundreds of students who used the book before him.

Escobosa said he believes a shift to tablets would be good, so long as it doesn’t segregate students.

“I can see few real downsides," he said. "The real issue would be in the case of those students without the means to access an online text, students without access to computers, iPads, etc. So a full-on removal of paper textbooks wouldn't be feasible, but a slow integration of e-books into schools would probably be better received."

To that end, Barlow said the school system has been discussing allowing students to bring their own iPads and devices to school for use in class. But they’re still working out the kinks. Monitoring and restricting Internet activity on the devices is currently out of the school system’s league.

“We're looking into it, but there’s a lot of pitfalls in there,” Barlow said. “It's something at least worth looking at, because that could knock down funding requirements if students could bring their own.”

Patch readers are currently being polled for this issue. So far, most are in favor of replacing textbooks. How do you feel?

Should iPads replace textbooks in the classroom? Let us know your opinion in the comments. Tell us in the comments.

Kate Treatman-Clark

6:12 pm on Wednesday, January 25, 2012

In the sciences, print textbooks are often outdated by the time they leave the publishers. Good teachers rarely make use of textbooks, instead integrating readings from original sources into the courses. Additionally, textbooks are ridiculously expensive and bulky. Their time has gone!

Reply

jesse55jp

7:38 pm on Wednesday, January 25, 2012

If every student gets a ipad then every county employee gets a 30% raise as a matter of general principal.

Reply

Amy Leahy

7:51 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

This absolutely blows my mind. On one hand our school superintendent writes his annual guest column begging for us to give the schools more money because they just couldn't possibly survive on the 52% of the county's budget they now receive. So if the schools cannot afford new textbooks to replace the ones that get damaged from normal wear and tear, how could they POSSIBLY afford to replace an iPAD that gets lost, stolen or falls into a toilet because teenagers are careless?

Reply

Jerri K.

8:58 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

This is a long term plan, and I think it is right for the school system, like any business or agency, to think big and plan for the future. We have been in contact with Mr. Barlow and other Board representatives about this, and have made the point for several years that this technology is imperative for many students on an IEP or 504 plan who have learning, developmental, or physical issues and really need this technology now to access education. I believe embracing it for this subset would be an excellent test of some of the issues practical parents and educators are concerned about -- restricting the Internet, loss, damage, or theft and how that can be insured, etc.

Reply

Myles Powers

10:02 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Why don't we just implant bio chips in every newborn? From what I see already there are too many young people who grow up not learning how to dig up information on third own. They are sucking up more and more bandwidth without producing any original thought. Kids to need to get outside, experience reality and learn to solve problems beyond a virtual world.

Reply

Faith Goldstein

10:33 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

How do you underline an IPAD? I can't imagine studying for an Exam without a highlighter, but then maybe testing is no longer necessary.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Tim Lemke

10:41 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Actually, e-reader programs do allow you to highlight, mark pages and take notes. I don't have any first-hand experience to know how it compares to real books, but I do know it's possible.

Dustin Winston

5:45 pm on Thursday, January 26, 2012

In the iBooks2 keynote last week, they actually demoed the highlighting capabilities of iBooks2. I think it would be a big mistake to invest in proprietary book formats like Apple iBooks that can't be used on ANY device. No school system should lock themselves into the Apple ecosystem. Would you buy a whole library of books if it could only be read with $500 Apple glasses?

Yes, books like current events, modern history, bio sciences, astronomy changes very often, but electronic books like Algebra, Calculus, 17th century history, should be fine for multiple decades. There is no reason the federal government couldn't commission 3 or 4 different Algebra I electronic books and make them freely available to everyone in the country. Why we are paying $75 per book every 4 years or so over the entire country is just a complete waste.

Reply

Martin Pinter

11:31 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012

If i had any say i would say no, but maybe yea if they can lock it to an app only what the teacher wants to show, because if not they will be sitting and playing games all day

Reply

Leave a comment